Published on

AOT-01-Option Analysis

Authors

1- Overview

1.1- Option context

  • What is the specific situation or context in which the option is being considered?
  • What are the goals or objectives that the option is intended to achieve, and how does it fit into the broader decision-making process?
  • Are there any constraints or limitations, such as time, resources, or legal or ethical considerations, that the option needs to take into account?
  • Who are the stakeholders, such as yourself, other individuals or groups, or the broader environment, that will be affected by the decision?

1.2- Option definition

  • What is the option you are considering, and how does it differ from other options or alternatives?
  • What is the rationale or justification for exploring this option, and what makes it worth considering?
  • Are there any assumptions or premises underlying the option, and how well-founded or supported are they by evidence or other information?
  • How does the option align with your personal values, beliefs, or goals, and how does it fit into your overall decision-making framework or strategy?

Try again

2- Outcome analysis

2.1- Potential Upside

  • What could you gain by choosing this option?
  • What are the potential upsides of this option, and how likely are they to occur?
  • What factors or determinants will influence the potential upside of this option?
  • What is your desired outcome or goal if you choose this option, and how does it align with your broader objectives or values?
  • What are the potential second-order or downstream effects of the most likely desired outcome?
  • How confident are you in the potential upsides of this option, and why?

2.2- Potential Downside

  • What will you sacrifice, if you implement this option?
  • What are the potential downsides of this option, and how likely are they to occur?
  • What factors or determinants will influence the potential downside of this option?
  • What are the potential second-order or downstream effects of the most likely undesired outcome?
  • How concerned are you about the potential downsides of this option, and why?

2.3- Ideas to enhance this option

  • What are the things you should do to perfect this option and enhance its potential upsides?
  • Are there any additional ideas or suggestions that could improve this option or reduce its potential downsides?
  • How will you incorporate or implement these ideas or suggestions into your decision-making process?

2.4- Outcome future assessment

  • How will you evaluate or assess the outcome of your decision?
  • What criteria or metrics will you use to measure the success or effectiveness of your decision?
  • How will you compare the actual outcome to your desired outcome or goals, and what feedback or lessons will you learn from this comparison?

3- Reversibility

3.1- Reversibility costs

  • After choosing this option, can you choose another one or change it?
  • What are the costs or implications of reversing or undoing your decision, such as the time, resources, or effort required, or the potential negative impacts or consequences of changing course?
  • What will happen if you decide to change your decision at a later date, and how will this affect your outcome or goals?
  • How will you plan or prepare for the possibility of reversing or changing your decision, and what contingencies or safeguards will you put in place?

3.2- Reversibility analysis

  • How will you assess or evaluate the reversibility of your decision?
  • What criteria or factors will you consider, such as the feasibility, cost, or potential impacts of reversing your decision?
  • How will you compare the reversibility of this option to other options or alternatives, and what will you learn from this comparison?
  • What implications or conclusions will you draw from your analysis of the reversibility of your decision, and how will this inform your decision-making process?

4- Risks

4.1- Concrete risks

  • What risks or uncertainties does this option imply, and how likely are they to occur?
  • What are the potential consequences or impacts of these risks, and how would they affect your outcome or goals?
  • Are there any known or identified risks that you need to consider or address, such as legal, financial, or operational risks?
  • How will you assess or evaluate the risks of this option, and how will you compare them to other options or alternatives?

4.2- Risk mitigation

  • What measures or strategies will you implement to mitigate or reduce the risks of this option, and how will you monitor or control them over time?
  • Are there any existing frameworks or tools that you can use to identify, assess, or manage risks, such as risk registers, impact assessments, or risk assessments?
  • How will you involve or consult with other stakeholders or experts to help you identify or mitigate risks, and what feedback or input will you seek from them?
  • What contingencies or backup plans will you have in place in case the risks materialize or the situation changes, and how will you implement or activate these plans?

4.3- Your personal concerns/ Fear

  • Is failure to achieve the desired outcome of this option something you can consider or accept?
  • What would the failure of this option imply for you personally, such as financial loss, reputational damage, or disappointment?
  • Are you prepared or able to cope with the potential consequences of failure, and what support or resources will you need to do so?
  • What worries or concerns you the most about this option, and how will you address or overcome these fears?
  • Is it challenging or difficult for you to take this path or make this decision, and what factors or obstacles are hindering your progress?
  • How will you manage or cope with your personal concerns or fears, and what support or resources will you need to do so?
  • How will you balance or weigh your personal concerns or fears against the potential rewards or benefits of this option, and how will this influence your decision-making process?

5- Influencing parameters

5.1- External influences

  • What parameters or factors could influence the choice of this option, and how will they affect your decision-making process?
  • How will external influences, such as market trends, regulatory changes, or competitive pressures, impact the potential outcome of this option?
  • What feedback or information will you need to gather from external sources or stakeholders to help you understand these influences?
  • How will you incorporate or factor in external influences into your decision-making process, and how will you account for their uncertainty or variability?

5.2- Luck/Skill

  • How will luck or chance influence the outcome of this option, and how will you account for this uncertainty in your decision-making process?
  • What skills or abilities will you need to implement or execute this option effectively, and how will you develop or acquire these skills?
  • How will you balance or trade-off luck or chance against skill or ability, and what factors or criteria will you use to make this assessment?
  • How will you determine or judge the difficulty of your task or goal, and what benchmarks or standards will you use to measure your performance or progress?

5.3- Other influencing parameters

  • What other influencing parameters or factors will you need to consider or address in your decision-making process, and how will you assess or evaluate their importance or impact?
  • What uncertainties or unknowns are you facing in relation to this option, and how will you manage or cope with these uncertainties?
  • On which parameters or factors do you have poor control or influence, and how will you mitigate or reduce the risks or implications of this lack of control?
  • On which parameters or factors do you have good control or influence, and how will you leverage or optimize this control to achieve your desired outcome or goal?

6- Stress Testing the option

6.1- Digging deeper

  • What potential negative consequences could arise from choosing this option?
  • What are the potential unintended consequences of each potential outcome?
  • Have you considered all of the potential implications of each outcome?
  • Are there any hidden costs or risks associated with this option?

6.2- Contrarian view

  • What would be the most compelling argument against choosing this option?
  • Have you considered the perspective of stakeholders who might have different priorities or interests?
  • Are there any potential drawbacks or downsides to this option that you have not considered?
  • Have you sought out input from others who might have a different perspective on this option?

6.3- Expected outcome

  • What needs to happen for each potential outcome to be realized?
  • How confident are you in your predictions of each potential outcome?
  • Have you considered the potential impact of external factors on the likelihood of each outcome?
  • Have you accounted for potential changes in circumstances or conditions that could affect the outcome?

6.4- Stress test's result

  • Have you thoroughly tested this option under different scenarios or assumptions?
  • Have you considered the potential impact of unexpected events or contingencies on the outcomes of this option?
  • Are there any potential risks or drawbacks that could arise from choosing this option that you have not accounted for?
  • Based on your stress testing, do you feel confident in your decision to choose this option?

6.5- Stress testing assumptions

  • What assumptions are you making about the potential outcomes of this option?
  • Have you considered the potential impact of changing your assumptions on the outcomes of this option?
  • Are there any potential risks or drawbacks associated with your assumptions?
  • Have you considered the potential impact of your assumptions on the decision-making process?

7- Best plan to maximize the option

7.1- Robustness

  • What potential threats or vulnerabilities could compromise the success of this option?
    • R1:
    • R2:
    • R3:
  • How likely are these threats or vulnerabilities to occur?
  • What steps can you take to mitigate or eliminate these threats or vulnerabilities?
    • R1:
    • R2:
    • R3:
  • Are there any potential weaknesses in your plan that could be exploited by others?
  • Are the assumptions you are relying on robust?
    • As1:
    • As2:.
    • As3:

7.2- Antifragility

  • What factors could cause this option to become less effective over time?
  • How can you make this option more resilient to changes in the environment or external factors?
  • What are the potential benefits of choosing this option in the long term?
  • How can you maximize the potential upsides of this option while minimizing the potential downsides?

7.3- Feedback

  • How will you monitor and evaluate the performance of this option over time?
  • What metrics or indicators will you use to measure the success or failure of this option?
  • How will you collect and analyze feedback from stakeholders or other interested parties?
  • What changes or adjustments will you make to your plan based on the feedback you receive?

7.4- Option maximization

  • What are the potential trade-offs or sacrifices that you will need to make in order to maximize the potential of this option?
  • How will you prioritize the various components of your plan to ensure that you are making the most effective use of your resources?
  • Are there any potential opportunities that you can capitalize on to maximize the potential of this option?
  • What additional information or resources do you need in order to fully realize the potential of this option?

7.5- Option comparison

  • How does this option compare to other options that you have considered?
  • What are the strengths and weaknesses of this option compared to the alternatives?
  • What factors or criteria are you using to evaluate the relative merits of different options?
  • Are there any additional factors or considerations that you need to take into account when comparing this option to others?

8- Option summary & Redefinition

8.1- Complementary information to gather

  • What additional information or data do you need in order to make a more informed decision about this option?
  • Where can you find this information or data?
  • Who can you talk to or consult with to gather additional insights or perspectives on this option?
  • What resources or tools can you use to help you gather and analyze the additional information you need?

8.2- Option scoring

  • What criteria or factors will you use to evaluate and compare the different options you are considering?
  • How will you assign weights or importance to each of these criteria or factors?
  • How will you score or rate each option based on these criteria or factors?
    • U1-
    • U2-
    • U3- | | U1 | U2 | U3 | General | | ---- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | | Cr1: | | --- | --- | | | Cr2 | | | | | | Cr3: | | | | | | Cr4: | | | | | | Cr5: | | | | |
  • How will you combine the individual scores to produce an overall score or rating for each option?

8.3- Option utility

  • What are the potential benefits or advantages of choosing this option?
  • What are the potential drawbacks or disadvantages of choosing this option?
  • How do the potential benefits and drawbacks of this option compare to those of the other options you are considering?
  • Are there any potential unintended consequences or risks associated with choosing this option?

8.4- Option evaluation

  • Based on your evaluation of this option, do you believe it is the best choice given your goals and priorities?
  • Are there any potential drawbacks or downsides to this option that you have not considered?
  • How confident are you in your evaluation of this option?
  • Are there any additional factors or considerations that you need to take into account before making a final decision?